Turn the focus on youth employment into lasting opportunity in Scotland
Developing the Young Workforce (DYW) Employer Network welcomes the focus on young people’s opportunities prompted by the Milburn review and supports an opportunity guarantee which provides a meaningful route into employment, education, training or tailored support. The task is to turn that ambition into lasting change across the UK, including Scotland.
Every young person deserves a fulfilling working life. That requires earlier investment, employers opening doors and support tailored to individual circumstances, including disability and health conditions.
A UK-wide challenge, a Scottish response
The independent Milburn review was commissioned by the UK Government, but education and skills are devolved in Scotland. Its recommendations must therefore be considered alongside Scotland’s existing provision. That does not lessen the challenge; Scotland must do more to help young people access opportunities and sustain progress towards work, building on its strengths without becoming complacent. Scotland’s strong initial positive-destination figures do not capture the considerable rise in young people not in education, employment or training beyond age 19, leaving a gap in our ability to measure lasting improvements in their lives.
The UK and Scottish Governments and DWP must agree with local delivery partners who is responsible for each part of the offer, how it will be funded and how services will work together. Furthermore, young people must have a meaningful say in designing and improving the support they receive. Any guarantee must strengthen existing partnerships, avoid duplication and work with Scotland’s education and skills system. Young people should experience coherent support, not have to navigate institutional boundaries.
Build on Scotland’s strengths
DYW’s employer-led network, delivered through 20 Regional Groups, connects employers, education and local partners. It helps young people explore industries and pathways and prepare for work, providing a practical foundation for stronger employer engagement. Those established relationships in communities are an asset to build on, not a substitute for the wider services young people need.
Scotland has experience to build on through the previous Young Person’s Guarantee (YPG), which aimed to connect every 16–24-year-old with an opportunity. There are foundations to build on and an opportunity to renew the principle of the Young Person’s Guarantee – that every young person in Scotland should have a meaningful opportunity to work, learn or train, with the support to take it up. This should build on the previous Guarantee’s achievements and lessons, rather than start again. The DYW Employer Network stands ready to support that ambition through its employer-led network and school partnerships.
As highlighted during Scottish Careers Week, employers already contribute through classroom activities, workplace visits, careers events and practical experiences. Sustained engagement and meaningful work-based experiences must remain central, while recognising the DYW Employer Network is one part of wider support.
High-quality careers information, advice and guidance must be central to the system, helping young people make informed judgements about the full range of pathways available and how these relate to their interests, strengths and ambitions. The DYW Employer Network can play an important supporting role through its presence in schools, complementing professional careers advice with employer insight and practical experiences of the world of work. These connections should help young people understand their options and make confident, informed choices about their future.
Opportunities must also align with the long-term needs of Scotland’s economy, not simply fill immediate vacancies. Government, education and employers should plan together for future skills demand, linking learning and work-based experiences to sustainable employment and progression. Matching young people’s ambitions with those needs will help create high-quality opportunities that last.
What are the next steps
There are opportunities for collective action in five key areas:
- Make an opportunity guarantee meaningful. Offer accessible, good-quality routes reflecting individual circumstances, with help to take them up. Interventions must support progression towards a future, not simply record participation.
- Invest early, with a long-term outlook. Embed repeated, meaningful employer engagement in education before young people become disconnected. Provide sustainable, multi-year funding so partnerships can plan. Present apprenticeships, vocational learning, college and university as equally ambitious choices.
- Make it practical for employers to take part. Recognise the time, supervision and resources required, especially for smaller businesses. Financial or recruitment-cost support should be clear, accessible and focused on quality. Provide straightforward contacts and help planning and supervising experiences.
- Join up support through transitions. Connect schools, colleges, training providers, employers, DWP and local services around young people. Involve them in shaping support, with preparation, ongoing help and clear handovers, so referrals, course starts or placements do not end support.
- Measure lasting progress. Look beyond exams, initial destinations and placement numbers. Track skills, confidence, equitable access and sustained learning or employment. Follow up to understand where progress lasts, where it breaks down and what further help is needed.
The DYW Employer Network stands ready to strengthen connections between learning and work alongside government, education, employers and the wider employability system. Scotland must build on what works, address gaps and give young people a fair chance to shape their future. The response to the Milburn Report should bring Scotland’s strengths and challenges together, turning renewed attention into opportunities that young people can experience.
Sandy Begbie CBE, Chair of the DYW Employers Forum, said:
“We welcome the focus on young people and support a guarantee offering a genuine route forward. Scotland must improve outcomes while building on DYW’s employer-led network. Employers are essential, and we must understand what helps businesses offer quality experiences and jobs, make participation practical and connect education with employers. The DYW Employer Network can be an integral part of Scotland’s response, helping turn ambition into meaningful opportunities while recognising that employers need support to contribute.”
Elma Murray CBE, Vice Chair of the DYW Employers Forum, said:
“A guarantee matters only if young people can take up opportunities. We need a long-term response that respects Scotland’s devolved responsibilities and provides wrap-around help with housing, mental health, financial pressures, transport and infrastructure. We must listen to young people, remove practical barriers and sustain support as they progress. This cannot be another short-term initiative: success depends on what the offer means for each young person, not simply on making it available.”